Search Content


Featured Content


Content Categories



On-premise and on-demand are like oil and water for SAP

This week's announcement that SAP has delayed the rollout of its hosted midmarket Business ByDesign offering, and reduced expectations for the product, shed further light on the difficulties that on-premise software companies will have in delivering software as a service.

It's not that SAP leadership doesnt get the opportunity, or isnt smart enough to capture it. I spent three years in the Office of the CEO and know better. But it takes more than smarts to overcome fundamental conflicts between the traditional enterprise software business model and the on-demand business model. Many lessons only come with experience in the market, and SAP's approach to try to build it all at once (as explained by SAP founder Hasso Plattner in his debate with Marc Benioff) is completely off the mark.

For example:

  • SAP locked 1,000 German engineers in an offsite location for five years to develop Business ByDesign. This follows the traditional model for building complex enterprise software. Software-as-a-Service (SaaS), on the other hand, allows, and flourishes with, continual refinement based on customer usage. This affects every aspect of the development lifecycle.
  • SAP built a system that was service oriented by design, but service delivery was an afterthought. SAP has never been in the service delivery business - this is an entirely new core competency, which happens to be at the core of how Salesforce and Google create value.
  • To avoid cannibalization of its core products, SAP has tightly restricted the target market for ByDesign to a narrow set of geographies and industries. Successful SaaS solutions, on the other hand, are adopted by the marketplace in a bottom-up fashion and spread virally, leading to surprising adoption patterns that result in new opportunities, such as Salesforce being used for Service and Support.

This week's announcement is bad news for SAPtheyve spent the last 2 years validating the potential of the SaaS market and now have to admit that it is far more difficult that then they anticipated to capture this opportunity.

Maybe SAP should take Benioff up on the challenge that he issued to Hasso at the Churchill Club, and build their next business application on Salesforce.com's Force.com platform. After all, SAPs core expertise is business processes, not in the technology or infrastructure required to deliver software as a service.

Narinder Singh

Related Salesforce Dedupe Articles

Avoiding Middle Management


Jason Kottke wrote a post earlier this week on solutions for avoiding middle management, and he made reference to Adaptive Paths advocacy program. Some folks emailed me directly for more information, so I thought Id share a bit more about how the...

Read more about Avoiding Middle Management...

The Most Popular Social Bookmarking Services


If you ever wanted to know how people are storing or sharing content on the web, this graph says this all. It shows a list of most popular social services that are used by netizens to share or save web pages. ...

Read more about The Most Popular Social Bookmarking Services...